Miami Private Investigations logoMiami Private InvestigationsCall (305) 686-7826

Miami Private Investigations

Long-Term Disability Claim Investigations in Florida

A disability investigation is only as good as its weakest day of reporting. The file that survives an appeal and a federal lawsuit is the one that shows everything observed -- including the hours when the claimant did nothing at all.

This page is for insurers, third-party administrators, self-insured employers and defence counsel handling long-term disability (LTD) claims. It is distinct from workers’ compensation, which is a state-law system for work injuries; that work is covered on our workers’ compensation investigations page. Disability insurance pays when a person cannot work because of illness or injury, whether or not it happened on the job, and when it is provided through an employer it is usually governed by federal law. Our broader liability and claims work is on the insurance defence investigation page.

Why the ERISA framework shapes the investigation

Most employer-sponsored LTD plans are governed by ERISA. Two provisions drive how investigative material is later tested:

Plans that are not governed by ERISA — some governmental, church and individually purchased policies — may be subject to different rules. Counsel will know which framework applies; the investigative standard below holds up under either.

What the claims regulation means for an investigator’s report

The practical rule: the report will be disclosed, rebutted and read by a federal judge. Write it as if the claimant’s lawyer is the first reader, because under the regulation they may well be.

What a lawful LTD investigation covers

What it never includes: medical records outside the claim process, bank or phone records, account access, trackers or pretext contact with the claimant’s doctors or employer. Those either come through the claims process and legal channels or not at all.

Report the quiet days too

An LTD surveillance report that shows only the forty minutes the claimant carried groceries — and omits the two days they did not leave the house — is the easiest document in the file to attack. Under a full and fair review standard, the claimant’s response will point to the omission, the treating physician will explain the good day as consistent with a fluctuating condition, and the selective report becomes evidence of an unfair process rather than of capacity.

So our reports account for the whole assignment:

The investigator documents what happened. Whether it is consistent with the claimed restrictions is a medical and vocational judgment for the plan’s reviewers, and the report is written to leave it there.

Fairness protects legitimate claimants and the decision

A balanced investigation is not a soft one. Many claimants are genuinely unable to work, and an accurate report that shows restricted activity supports paying the claim as much as an accurate report of inconsistent activity supports reviewing it. Either way, the decision rests on facts that can be defended. That is the point of the work: a reliable record, not a predetermined outcome.

Common mistakes that weaken an LTD file

Working with the claim file

Assignments arrive at different stages: on an initial claim, during a periodic review, when the definition of disability changes under the plan’s terms, or during an appeal. The stage matters, because evidence generated during an appeal triggers the disclosure and response rights described above, and the schedule needs to allow for them.

Good assignments start with the claimant’s stated restrictions, the treating provider’s description of limitations, the claimed onset and any known schedule, such as medical appointments. That lets surveillance be timed to days that are informative and lets the report speak to the actual restrictions in issue. We report what we observe; claim decisions belong to the plan.

For other claims work, including liability and first-party matters, see our claim investigation services.

Miami Private Investigations is licensed in Florida under agency licence A1800135 and works for insurers, administrators, employers and defence firms across Miami-Dade and statewide from our Coral Gables office at 4000 Ponce de Leon Boulevard, Suite 470. Reports are written so the investigator who produced them can explain and stand behind every entry. Every assignment is scoped and quoted per case. Call (305) 686-7826 or contact us for a confidential consultation.

Frequently Asked Questions

What law governs most long-term disability claims?

Most employer-sponsored long-term disability plans are governed by ERISA. A participant may sue to recover benefits due under the terms of the plan under 29 U.S.C. § 1132(a)(1)(B), and the claims process must meet the Department of Labor’s regulation at 29 C.F.R. § 2560.503-1. Some governmental, church and individual policies follow different rules; counsel can confirm which applies.

Will the claimant see the surveillance report?

Assume so. Under 29 C.F.R. § 2560.503-1(h)(2)(iii), a claimant may request, at no charge, reasonable access to and copies of documents relevant to the claim, and for disability claims paragraph (h)(4)(i) requires new or additional evidence relied upon on review to be provided in time for the claimant to respond.

How is a disability claim investigation different from a workers' comp investigation?

Workers’ compensation is a state-law system for injuries arising from work. Long-term disability insurance pays when a person cannot work because of illness or injury, whether or not it is work-related, and employer plans are usually governed by federal ERISA rules with their own claims-procedure requirements.

Is surveillance of a disability claimant legal in Florida?

Video surveillance of activity in places open to public view is lawful when conducted by a licensed agency. We record video without audio and never film where a person has an expectation of privacy. We do not use trackers, account access or pretext contact.

Why include days with no activity in the report?

Because the claimant is entitled to see and respond to the evidence, and the review must consider everything submitted. A report that shows only active moments invites the argument that it was selective. Reporting every observation period, including inactivity and signs of limitation, is what makes the useful hours credible.

Does the investigator decide whether the claimant can work?

No. The investigator records what was observed, with times and conditions. Whether that activity is consistent with the claimed restrictions is a medical and vocational judgment for the plan’s reviewers.

Can an investigation help a legitimate claimant?

Yes. An accurate report that documents restricted activity supports the claim as clearly as an accurate report of inconsistent activity supports further review. Balanced reporting protects genuine claimants and the defensibility of the decision.

Talk to a licensed investigator — confidential consultation

Every consultation with Miami Private Investigations is completely confidential. Serving Miami-Dade County & South Florida.

Call (305) 686-7826