This page is for insurers, third-party administrators, self-insured employers and defence counsel handling long-term disability (LTD) claims. It is distinct from workers’ compensation, which is a state-law system for work injuries; that work is covered on our workers’ compensation investigations page. Disability insurance pays when a person cannot work because of illness or injury, whether or not it happened on the job, and when it is provided through an employer it is usually governed by federal law. Our broader liability and claims work is on the insurance defence investigation page.
Why the ERISA framework shapes the investigation
Most employer-sponsored LTD plans are governed by ERISA. Two provisions drive how investigative material is later tested:
- The lawsuit. Under 29 U.S.C. § 1132(a)(1)(B) — ERISA’s civil enforcement provision — a participant or beneficiary may bring a civil action to recover benefits due under the terms of the plan, to enforce rights under the plan, or to clarify rights to future benefits. An investigation report in an LTD file should be written on the assumption that it will be read in that action.
- The claims procedure. The Department of Labor’s claims-procedure regulation, 29 C.F.R. § 2560.503-1, requires a “full and fair review” of an adverse benefit determination under paragraph (h)(1). For disability claims it adds specific protections that bear directly on investigative material.
Plans that are not governed by ERISA — some governmental, church and individually purchased policies — may be subject to different rules. Counsel will know which framework applies; the investigative standard below holds up under either.
What the claims regulation means for an investigator’s report
- The claimant can see it. Under § 2560.503-1(h)(2)(iii), a claimant is entitled on request, at no charge, to reasonable access to and copies of documents relevant to the claim. Assume the claimant and their attorney will read every word.
- The claimant can answer it. For disability claims, paragraph (h)(4)(i) requires that any new or additional evidence considered, relied upon or generated in connection with the claim be provided to the claimant, at no charge, sufficiently in advance of the decision on review to give a reasonable opportunity to respond. A surveillance report obtained during an appeal is exactly that kind of evidence.
- The review considers everything. Under (h)(2)(ii) and (h)(2)(iv), the claimant may submit written comments, documents and records, and the review must take all of it into account whether or not it was considered initially. A report that is selective will be met by a response that is not.
- Decision-makers must be impartial. Paragraph (b)(7) requires disability claims to be adjudicated in a manner designed to ensure the independence and impartiality of the people making decisions, including medical and vocational experts.
- Treating providers’ views must be addressed. Under (g)(1)(vii)(A)(i), a disability denial notice must discuss the basis for disagreeing with or not following the views of the claimant’s treating health care professionals. Investigative findings are often part of that explanation, which means they must be accurate enough to be put next to a physician’s opinion.
What a lawful LTD investigation covers
- Activity checks. Confirming the basics: that the claimant lives where the file says, the household, the vehicles at the address, and whether there are visible signs of a business or regular departure for work. Neighbour canvasses, if requested, are conducted with truthful identification.
- Surveillance. Time-stamped video of the claimant in places open to public view, documenting activity as it happens. Video only — no audio — and never in places where a person has an expectation of privacy. See surveillance investigations.
- Public social media and online activity. Publicly visible posts, business pages, listings and profiles, captured with URL, timestamps and a collection record. We do not use fake accounts or friend requests. See social media investigation.
- Employment and business activity. Corporate filings, fictitious names, professional licences, permits and public business listings that may show self-employment or work inconsistent with the stated restrictions.
- Licensing and records research. Professional licence status, public discipline and court records relevant to the claim, matched to the claimant on identifiers beyond the name.
What it never includes: medical records outside the claim process, bank or phone records, account access, trackers or pretext contact with the claimant’s doctors or employer. Those either come through the claims process and legal channels or not at all.
Report the quiet days too
An LTD surveillance report that shows only the forty minutes the claimant carried groceries — and omits the two days they did not leave the house — is the easiest document in the file to attack. Under a full and fair review standard, the claimant’s response will point to the omission, the treating physician will explain the good day as consistent with a fluctuating condition, and the selective report becomes evidence of an unfair process rather than of capacity.
So our reports account for the whole assignment:
- every period of observation, with start and end times, including periods of no activity;
- the conditions — vantage point, weather, obstructions — so the reader knows what could and could not be seen;
- activity described as observed, with duration, without medical conclusions;
- signs of limitation recorded as carefully as signs of capacity: a limp, use of a cane, rest breaks, assistance from others;
- video that is continuous where practical, with gaps explained.
The investigator documents what happened. Whether it is consistent with the claimed restrictions is a medical and vocational judgment for the plan’s reviewers, and the report is written to leave it there.
Fairness protects legitimate claimants and the decision
A balanced investigation is not a soft one. Many claimants are genuinely unable to work, and an accurate report that shows restricted activity supports paying the claim as much as an accurate report of inconsistent activity supports reviewing it. Either way, the decision rests on facts that can be defended. That is the point of the work: a reliable record, not a predetermined outcome.
Common mistakes that weaken an LTD file
- Surveillance without a question. Watching a claimant with no reference to the stated restrictions produces footage that proves little either way. The assignment should name the restrictions in issue — lifting, sitting, driving, walking distance — so the report can speak to them.
- Treating one active day as the answer. Many conditions fluctuate. A single observation of activity, without context about frequency and duration, rarely supports much on its own and is easily explained in rebuttal.
- Edited or summarised video. A highlights reel invites the question of what was cut. Continuous footage, with any gaps logged and explained, is far harder to attack.
- Conclusions the investigator is not qualified to draw. Phrases like “no apparent disability” belong nowhere in an investigative report. They undermine the report and the reviewer who relies on it.
- Misidentified subjects. Filming a relative or neighbour by mistake is avoidable, and fatal to credibility when it happens. Identification is confirmed and documented before activity is attributed to the claimant.
- Online material without a collection record. A screenshot with no URL, date or account identifier cannot be relied on, and the claimant is entitled to challenge it.
Working with the claim file
Assignments arrive at different stages: on an initial claim, during a periodic review, when the definition of disability changes under the plan’s terms, or during an appeal. The stage matters, because evidence generated during an appeal triggers the disclosure and response rights described above, and the schedule needs to allow for them.
Good assignments start with the claimant’s stated restrictions, the treating provider’s description of limitations, the claimed onset and any known schedule, such as medical appointments. That lets surveillance be timed to days that are informative and lets the report speak to the actual restrictions in issue. We report what we observe; claim decisions belong to the plan.
For other claims work, including liability and first-party matters, see our claim investigation services.
Miami Private Investigations is licensed in Florida under agency licence A1800135 and works for insurers, administrators, employers and defence firms across Miami-Dade and statewide from our Coral Gables office at 4000 Ponce de Leon Boulevard, Suite 470. Reports are written so the investigator who produced them can explain and stand behind every entry. Every assignment is scoped and quoted per case. Call (305) 686-7826 or contact us for a confidential consultation.
Our licensed private investigators in Miami work from Coral Gables across Miami-Dade and statewide, and every engagement starts with a confidential consultation.
Miami Private Investigations