Miami Private Investigations logoMiami Private InvestigationsCall (305) 686-7826

Miami Private Investigations

Researching a Witness Before a Deposition in Florida

By the time a witness sits down for a deposition, the most useful questions are the ones you already know the answers to. Credibility research is how counsel gets there -- and in Florida the Evidence Code tells you exactly which facts are worth finding.

This page is about a witness you have already identified and can reach through the ordinary process. If you still need to find the person, that is a different job, covered on our witness location page. If the question is whether the investigator can take the stand, see can a private investigator testify in court in Florida. What follows is the research that happens in between: learning who the witness is before opposing counsel’s preparation session does it for them.

Nothing here is legal advice. Whether and how a fact is used is counsel’s decision. Our job is to find it lawfully, confirm it, and document where it came from.

Start with what the Evidence Code says matters

Under s. 90.608, F.S. — “Who may impeach” — any party, including the party calling the witness, may attack credibility by:

That list doubles as a research plan. Each heading points to a different set of records, and a good pre-deposition file is organised the same way, so counsel can see at a glance which line of impeachment the material supports.

Prior statements: the most valuable thing to find

A witness who has described the same events before — in an earlier lawsuit, an insurance claim, a police report, an administrative hearing, a recorded interview or a public post — has created a benchmark. Section 90.614, F.S., “Prior statements of witnesses,” governs how those statements are used: extrinsic evidence of a prior inconsistent statement is generally not admissible unless the witness is first afforded an opportunity to explain or deny it, and becomes admissible if the witness denies or does not distinctly admit making it. The practical point for preparation is simple: counsel needs the statement before the deposition, verified and sourced, to put it to the witness properly.

Where prior statements typically live:

Bias and interest

Bias is rarely announced. It shows up in relationships: a business connection with a party on Sunbiz, a shared address in property records, a prior lawsuit between the witness and the opposing party, an employment link, a family relationship, or a financial stake in the outcome. Those connections are largely documented in public records, and they are easy to miss unless someone is deliberately looking for them across corporate, property and court systems.

Convictions: precise records, not a database hit

Under s. 90.610, F.S., “Conviction of certain crimes as impeachment,” a witness may be attacked with evidence of a conviction for a crime punishable by death or imprisonment in excess of one year, or for a crime involving dishonesty or a false statement regardless of punishment. In civil trials there is an exception for convictions too remote in time to be relevant to present character, and juvenile adjudications are excluded. A pardon or a pending appeal does not make the conviction inadmissible.

That framework turns on details a commercial background report does not reliably provide: the exact offence, its classification, the disposition and the date. Our work is to pull the actual court record in the correct county, confirm the identity of the defendant against the witness, and report the disposition as the court recorded it. Whether a particular disposition qualifies is a question for counsel; ensuring the record is the right person’s and accurately described is ours.

The namesake problem. The fastest way to lose credibility of your own is to impeach a witness with someone else’s conviction. Every criminal or civil record we report is matched to the witness on identifiers beyond the name, and where the match is not certain, the report says so.

Character for truthfulness

Section 90.609, F.S., “Character of witness as impeachment,” limits this route: it uses reputation evidence, it is confined to character relating to truthfulness, and evidence of truthful character is admissible only after that character has been attacked by reputation evidence. Research here is about identifying people who may know the witness’s reputation in a relevant community, so counsel can decide whether the route is worth pursuing. It is not about collecting gossip.

Capacity, ability and opportunity to observe

Where the witness says they were, what they could have seen from there, and whether the timeline holds up are factual questions. Lawful research can test them: the location and its sightlines, the public record of the witness’s employment or schedule at the time, and anything the witness has publicly posted about their whereabouts. When the scene matters, documenting it is part of the same pre-suit or trial preparation work.

Licensing, discipline and professional history

Professionals and experts are a special case. Licensing boards publish licence status and, often, public discipline. Expert witnesses may have testified in other cases on similar issues, and published opinions, prior reports filed as exhibits, and professional publications can show positions that sit uneasily with the current testimony. Litigation history — how often a lay witness has been a party to suits or claims — can also bear on interest and pattern.

Public social media, collected properly

Publicly visible posts are often the richest source of prior statements and relationships. They are also the easiest to collect badly. A screenshot from a client’s phone is a lead, not an exhibit. We capture the page as served, with the URL, account identifier, timestamps and a collection record, so the material can be authenticated. The detail is in our guide on social media evidence in a Florida lawsuit.

When to start, and why it matters

Credibility research is most useful well before the deposition notice goes out. Court files in other counties may need to be requested rather than downloaded; certified copies take time to obtain; and public posts can be deleted or made private once a witness learns they will be questioned. Starting early also lets the research shape the outline: a prior lawsuit discovered in advance becomes a line of questions, while one discovered the night before is usually a missed opportunity.

The same file carries forward. Material developed before a deposition is checked again before trial, because circumstances change — a new case is filed, a licence is disciplined, a witness posts about the litigation. A short update search before trial is often where the most current, and most persuasive, material appears.

Lay witnesses, experts and corporate representatives

The research plan differs by witness. For a lay eyewitness, the focus is usually relationships, prior statements and opportunity to observe. For a retained expert, it is prior testimony, publications, positions taken in similar cases and licence history. For a corporate representative, it is the company’s own public filings, prior litigation and statements the business has made publicly about the subject. Telling us which kind of witness it is, and what the witness is expected to say, keeps the work focused on what can actually be used.

What this research never involves

Those limits are not just ethics; they protect the material. Credibility evidence gathered by deception invites a fight about the investigator instead of the witness.

What counsel receives

Miami Private Investigations is licensed in Florida under agency licence A1800135 and supports plaintiff and defence firms across Miami-Dade and statewide. Every matter is scoped and quoted per case. Call (305) 686-7826 or contact us for a confidential consultation.

Frequently Asked Questions

How can a witness be impeached in Florida?

Under s. 90.608, F.S., any party may attack a witness’s credibility by introducing prior inconsistent statements, showing bias, attacking character under s. 90.609 or s. 90.610, showing a defect of capacity, ability or opportunity to observe, remember or recount, or proving through other witnesses that material facts are not as testified. How those tools apply in a given case is a question for counsel.

What convictions can be used to impeach a witness in Florida?

Under s. 90.610, F.S., a conviction for a crime punishable by death or imprisonment in excess of one year, or for a crime involving dishonesty or a false statement regardless of punishment. In civil trials, convictions too remote in time may be excluded, and juvenile adjudications are not admissible for this purpose. A pardon or pending appeal does not make the conviction inadmissible.

Can character evidence be used to attack a witness's credibility?

Within limits. Section 90.609, F.S. allows reputation evidence only, only as to character relating to truthfulness, and evidence of truthful character is admissible only after the character for truthfulness has been attacked by reputation evidence.

Why do I need a witness's prior statements before the deposition?

Because s. 90.614, F.S. generally requires that a witness be given an opportunity to explain or deny a prior inconsistent statement before extrinsic evidence of it is admitted. Having the verified statement in hand before the deposition lets counsel put it to the witness properly.

Is a commercial background report enough for impeachment?

Rarely. Aggregated reports often blend people with similar names and summarise dispositions inaccurately. Impeachment requires the actual court record, from the correct county, matched to the witness on identifiers beyond the name.

Will an investigator contact the witness?

Only on counsel’s instruction, with truthful identification, and never a person known to be represented by counsel about the subject of the matter. Much credibility research involves no contact with the witness at all.

Does witness research include the witness's private social media or phone records?

No. We collect only what is publicly visible, with a documented capture. Private account content, phone records and bank records reach a case, if at all, through legal process such as a subpoena.

Talk to a licensed investigator — confidential consultation

Every consultation with Miami Private Investigations is completely confidential. Serving Miami-Dade County & South Florida.

Call (305) 686-7826